Logistics Manager
  • Logistics
    • A-E
      • 3rd Party Logistics
      • Air Cargo
      • Coronavirus
      • Express & e-delivery
      • Editor’s Blog
    • F-M
      • Health & Safety
      • International logistics
      • Latest issue
      • Logistics & Supply Chain
    • O-Z
      • Ocean Freight
      • Policy and legislation
      • Professional development
      • Rail freight
      • Road transport
      • Sustainability
      • Temperature-controlled
  • Intralogistics
    • Automation
    • Commercial Vehicles
    • Equipment
    • Infrastructure & Services
    • IT & Software
    • Materials handling
    • Packaging
    • Picking and sortation
    • Robotics and innovation
    • Storage
  • Supply Chain
    • A-L
      • Automotive
      • Construction
      • Energy
      • Fashion
      • Food & drink
      • Forecasting
      • Healthcare and Pharma
      • Hi-tech
    • M-Z
      • Manufacturing
      • Military
      • Omni-channel
      • Public Sector
      • Retail
      • SME
      • Sourcing and procurement
      • Supply Chain Analysis
      • Supply Chain Awards
      • Supply Chain Strategy
      • Supply Chain Technology
      • Supply Chain Visibility
      • Technology
  • Property
    • A-M
      • Big Sheds
      • Design & Build
      • East Midlands and East Anglia
      • M25 East
      • M25 West
      • Mid-box
    • M-Z
      • North East & Yorkshire
      • North West
      • Scotland
      • South-West & Wales
      • Speculative Development
      • Urban Warehouses
      • West Midlands
  • Corporate Insight
  • Digital Magazines
    • June 2023
    • May 2023
    • April 2023
    • March 2023
    • February 2023
    • January 2023
  • Events
    • Sustainable Supply Chain Conference
    • ESG Industrial & Logistics Conference
    • Supply Chain Excellence Awards
    • CiTTi Awards
    • IntraLogisteX
    • Robotics & Automation
  • Webinars
LinkedIn Twitter
  • Subscribe
  • Free weekly e-newsletter
  • Free daily e-newsletter
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
LinkedIn Twitter
Logistics Manager
SUBSCRIBE >
  • Logistics
      • 3rd Party Logistics
      • Air Cargo
      • Coronavirus
      • Express & e-delivery
      • Editor’s Blog
      • Health & Safety
      • International logistics
      • Latest issue
      • Logistics & Supply Chain
      • Ocean Freight
      • Policy and legislation
      • Professional development
      • Rail freight
      • Road transport
      • Sustainability
      • Temperature-controlled
  • Intralogistics
      • Automation
      • Commercial Vehicles
      • Equipment
      • Infrastructure & Services
      • IT & Software
      • Materials handling
      • Packaging
      • Picking and sortation
      • Robotics and innovation
      • Storage
  • Supply Chain
      • Automotive
      • Construction
      • Energy
      • Fashion
      • Food & drink
      • Forecasting
      • Healthcare and Pharma
      • Hi-tech
      • Manufacturing
      • Military
      • Omni-channel
      • Public Sector
      • Retail
      • SME
      • Sourcing and procurement
      • Supply Chain Analysis
      • Supply Chain Awards
      • Supply Chain Strategy
      • Supply Chain Technology
      • Supply Chain Visibility
      • Technology
  • Property
      • Big Sheds
      • Design & Build
      • East Midlands and East Anglia
      • M25 East
      • M25 West
      • Mid-box
      • North East & Yorkshire
      • North West
      • Scotland
      • South-West & Wales
      • Speculative Development
      • Urban Warehouses
      • West Midlands
  • Corporate Insight
  • Events
    • Events News
      • Conferences
      • Exhibitions
      • Top 50
    • Sustainable Supply Chain Conference
    • Industrial & Logistics Property Conference
    • Supply Chain Excellence Awards
    • CiTTi Awards
    • IntraLogisteX
    • Robotics & Automation
  • Digital Magazines
    1. December 2023
    2. November 2023
    3. October 2023
    4. September 2023
    5. August 2023
    6. July 2023
    7. June 2023
    Featured

    Logistics Manager Magazine December 2023

    4th December 2023By James McLoughlin
    Recent
    4th December 2023

    Logistics Manager Magazine December 2023

    6th November 2023

    Logistics Manager Magazine November 2023

    2nd October 2023

    Logistics Manager Magazine October 2023

  • Webinars
LinkedIn Twitter
Logistics Manager
Article

The innovative trailblazer

wpengineBy wpengine1st June 200413 Mins Read
LinkedIn Twitter Email Facebook

US-based group Procter & Gamble (P&G) manufactures and markets nearly 300 brands of consumer products including houseold names Lenor, Ariel, Pampers, Sunny Delight and Pringles. With a workforce of nearly 100,000 worldwide, the group operates in nearly 80 countries worldwide and made net sales of almost US$43.4Bn (£24.5Bn) in the 12 months to June 2003.

However while the organisation was built up into the “fantastically good” manufacturing organisation that it is today its supply chain was inefficient. As a result the company has been transforming its UK supply chain into an efficient and collaborative operation. This process has involved implementing a range of innovative schemes to help optimise and consolidate the supply chain and the group’s “first time fill rate” for customers now stands at 99%.

The transformation has proved so successful that the trailblazing ideas are now being introduced elsewhere within P&G’s European supply chain.

The challenge of revolutionising the group’s UK supply chain has been the responsibility of Chris Poole (pictured), P&G’s logistics director for the UK and Ireland and co-chair of consumer industry body ECR UK. The group’s new philosophy, explains Poole, is all about “winning at the first moment of truth. It is important that we make sure product is there at the store, looks good on the shelf, and has been delivered in the most cost-efficient way so that those cost savings can be ultimately incorporated into a lower cost. That’s not new. It’s just about great service and low costs, and trying to get that balance”.

For P&G there are two moments of truth:- l”On the shelf” – if consumers get to the shelf and the product is not there, they cannot buy it. The moment of truth here is whether the consumer will remain faithful to P&G’s product or choose a rival’s.

lThe second moment of truth is when the consumer, having bought the product, gets it home. Will the product do what it says it will?

The transformation of P&G’s UK supply chain began after three areas were identified that had to be dealt with in order to deliver a great on-shelf service. Poole explains: “The first is that we have to deliver a great basic service, we have to be good at the fundamentals. We don’t have the licence to do anything else with customers unless we are fantastic at that. Secondly, we have to and want to collaborate very closely with customers. We can’t do it by ourselves. And thirdly, we must work now on the future. We have to be innovative.”

Poole continues: “That’s different to what it was maybe five to six years ago where we were a fantastically good manufacturing organisation with a push out rather than an external focus starting with the shelf, and following the whole supply chain backwards. That is not how we did it. We were inefficient.

“The great basic service is about delivering what customers want, damage-free and on time, and we weren’t very good at that five years ago. We had a measure of missed cases – availability was 96% and the number of missed cases 4%. We were probably delivering only two-thirds of our order on time. We weren’t good enough.”

The 4% of missed cases amounted to seven or eight million cases a year and cost P&G an estimated £40M. “We were losing a lot of money each year so we put in place some big changes both in terms of the systems and processes that we had within the company and the physical infrastructure,” says Poole.

As a result P&G invested in providing much greater capability in demand driven logistics – its ultimate aim – starting with synchronising the supply chain in line with consumer demand. “We invested over US$40M to upgrade our whole logistics infrastructure.”

The changes included:-

lFocusing on supplier relationship management and improving the speed and accuracy of information flow up the supply chain.

lCreating two distribution centres in the North and South to deliver the full range of P&G’s ambient products on one truck.

lIntroducing innovative schemes such as cross-docking so that products bypass storage, saving time and resources by going straight onto store shelves.

lUsing IT solutions such as GPS tracking and electronic proof of delivery.

Reduced inventory

The transformation began with Procter & Gamble’s physical infrastructure. It had three sites from which customers could order products – paper towels and nappies were produced at Manchester, laundry products at London and some toiletries at Skelmersdale – which forced customers to buy from three different places, rather than in line with demand. The group decided to give customers the opportunity to buy its whole ambient range from one place so that they could take advantage of efficient truck load ordering and ordering less quantity more often, enabling them to order much more in line with demand.

P&G also built a brand new automated distribution centre (DC) at its London plant next to the Queen Elizabeth II Bridge at Dartford and upgraded its existing DC at Skelmersdale.

Poole says that those changes alone had a drastic effect on the supply chain. He comments: “That was good because it meant there was fewer inventory in the total supply chain.

The group also recognised the advantages of enabling its larger customers to buy direct from the plants. Customers can go through the service centres and buy a truck full of anything they want. Also, for the physically big fast moving bulky items like nappies and soap powder they can order them direct from the plants.

Poole says: “We’ve done that to a certain extent already from our London and Manchester factories – London makes laundry products and Manchester makes nappies and kitchen towel – and we are extending that to other plants that are on the Continent.”

P&G is operating a two-tier distribution network which has drastically improved the basic service, says Poole.

Over the past 15 months the percentage of missed cases has reduced from 4% to less than 0.5%. However, Poole says that while there are still more opportunities for further improvement, the interventions made so far have led to a big change in the service provided. “The intervention that we made was critical, and that has given us the licence to get in and really work with customers more closely.”

Collaborative planning

According to Poole a lot of people talk about demand driven logistics but P&G was one of the first of its size to “actually put our money where our mouth is and make that change”. He says the development has helped better supply chain information synchronisation because the group is delivering to demand. Losses – reduced inventory and fewer truck miles – have been cut out of the supply chain.

Having transformed the physical aspect of its supply chain, P&G turned its attention to having the right systems and processes in place so that it could collaborate with customers.

Changes here have included the creation of the Team Room, an area that has taken all the different disciplines of approach that the plants employ concerning day-by-day production and applied it to a logistics environment, putting daily, weekly, monthly and annual processes in place and ensuring that everybody works on the right system in the first place.

Poole says: “That was the other part of the jigsaw, and in the Team Room one of the walls features the annual plan, strategies and where we are on each of those. We also have a daily meeting at 8.30am between all elements of the supply chain – the service centre, the DCs, the people that work with customers, the market planners and our order management people – so that everyone knows what happened yesterday, what’s going to happen today and what needs to happen with customers.”

Promotion forecasting was one area that had to be tackled and the Team Room has a board which highlights all the critical elements in putting together a big promotion. “Everyone can see whether things have been done or not.”

Poole says that a typical promotion can be for a physically big bulky product such as tissue towel for a supermarket chain. The number of cases involved could be at least 100,000. Poole cites another example where in the lead up to Christmas and he and his team and to ship cases of snack food Pringles to one of P&G’s major customers. Poole says 150 40ft trucks were used over the Christmas period.

P&G has also introduced joint forecasting within its supply chain. Poole explains: “Joint forecasting is about sitting down and agreeing quantities and delivery times together so that there are no surprises. With each of our customers we set up joint forecasting processes and for big customers and big promotions the forecasting detail – when they need it, how much is needed and delivery time – has to be signed off by the logistics and the commercial people on both sides so that everybody knows what the deal is. The nightmares only come because there are surprises through lack of communication.”

Working with customers has improved P&G’s service levels but, says Poole, the crusade continues. “Collaboration with customers is critical. You have to get in with the customers and understand what they want, working through the solution. Anything that improves service on shelf and reduces total supply chain costs from the factory gate outwards is up for grabs.

“What we don’t want is to shunt value around the supply chain. We used to do that when customers had three sources to deal with – we were saying ‘to get the best price you’ve got to order a truckload’ and they would do that. What we were actually doing was washing our hands of it, and that wasn’t good enough. All we did there was shunt the inventory and the problem onto another supply chain.”

Poole stresses that companies have to sit down with customers and create a “logistics hit-list” highlighting the areas that will be mutually beneficial, improve service and reduce total supply chain costs. “That’s the basis of our collaboration with any customer – let’s work together to find the best way to improve service and reduce costs.”

In transforming its supply chain, P&G also approached major customers for input on improving its supply chain. “That’s not to say we did everything they said,” says Poole, “but we listened to them. And that’s how it continues now. The collaboration work is based on what we can do to improve the flow of information up the supply chain; how we can make that faster and more accurate.”

Future developments

The aim, says Poole, is to achieve demand driven logistics where P&G ultimately delivers exactly in line with a consumer buying a product. “You’re never going to get that but the closer you can get to that ideal, the better.”

P&G wants to push product up through the supply chain – not push it down – and the group is already working on innovative schemes to progress that including working with customers on data synchronisation. The group already trades with all its customers through EDI for order acquisition and payment – about 92% of orders are done electronically – and is continually working on joint forecasting.

“Our ideal would be to produce to demand, rather than produce to forecast as we do now. It would make the manufacturing part of our supply chain more efficient, more responsive. Ultimately that could be delivery straight to shelf, although putting in the techniques or the mechanics to do that would be another thing, ” he says.

In terms of developing innovative schemes for the future, Procter & Gamble is currently implementing trials with customers. One such trial concerns cross-docking some of its products. Product arrives at a customer’s warehouse but rather than being put away in racking, it is picked and sorted immediately. Such a development would prove useful for some products, especially big and bulky items like tissue towel which take up so much space in the warehouse.

Poole says other innovative developments that P&G is getting into include making it easier for product to get from a store’s back door through to the shelf. “I can’t on the one hand say this is all about first moment of truth and then say ‘OK, we’ll abandon product once it gets to the customer’s back door’.”

He believes there are things that suppliers can do to achieve that aim. P&G is currently trialling with Tesco wheeled dollies for promotions. However, he acknowledges both the advantages and the disadvantages of using such a system: “To be able to put dollies on the bottom of each pallet is a monumental task. However, that investment is likely to be worthwhile because the extra in-store presence that we get, and therefore extra sales, mitigates the extra effort.”

The group is also trialling at a Tesco store in the North-west the use of wheeled half pallets for laundry cleaning products. P&G is also looking at making sure its product is easily distinguishable in the back room of a store or a warehouse to ensure pickers select the right product, a visual approach as opposed to seeking out a barcode.

He says retailers have not got anywhere else to build shops “in an organic growth kind of way” so they are trying to make much more use of the space in the store.

“Working with customers to understand how we help them in the last 50 yards is something that we are working on right now, and there’s probably a lot more that we can do. The be all and end all is whether the product on the shelf. We have to go right through to the shelf.”

Procter & Gamble is also developing a “satellite pen” for signatures and is thinking about providing 24/7 deliveries. “We need to be ready for that and be aware of quality on the shelf. We need to ensure products look good and fresh,” explains Poole.

According to Poole the fundamentals of logistics will never change – it is about servicing cost, although going through to the future it is all about finding ways that are positive to increasing service, and that do not bring extra cost into the supply chain.

Since it made the investment in the London and Skelmersdale facilities, which only came online about a year ago, P&G bought Clairol and its business has grown 7% or 8% year-on-year. “We’re full. So we need to update them, and are making significant investment to expand London and Skelmersdale as well to meet our logistics requirements for the next five to ten years.”

Despite all that, Poole believes collaboration with customers is key to an efficient supply chain. He concludes: “A real focus on joint and collaborative planning with customers has been critical. It’s all very well putting in great capability and structurally changing our supply chain but at the end of the day you can’t make it happen unless you work with your customer.” n

Share. LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email
wpengine
  • Website

This is the "wpengine" admin user that our staff uses to gain access to your admin area to provide support and troubleshooting. It can only be accessed by a button in our secure log that auto generates a password and dumps that password after the staff member has logged in. We have taken extreme measures to ensure that our own user is not going to be misused to harm any of our clients sites.

Related Stories

Major HGV decarbonisation needed to meet net zero, report claims

30th November 2023

Research shows nearly half of Black Friday returns were paid for

30th November 2023

The Top 50 Logistics Service Providers 2023

28th November 2023
Latest News Stories
4th December 2023

Logistics Manager Magazine December 2023

1st December 2023

Tesla’s legal battle with Swedish authorities amid labour dispute

30th November 2023

Major HGV decarbonisation needed to meet net zero, report claims

Free weekly e-newsletters

Discover what’s causing a stir in the world of logistics and supply chains


Key Content
  • Digital Magazines
  • Logistics
  • Intralogistics
  • Supply Chain
  • Property
  • Corporate Insight
  • Events News
  • Opinion
Akabo Media
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Free Daily E-Newsletter
  • Free Weekly Top Stories E-Newsletters
  • Free Weekly Supply Chain E-Newsletter
  • Free Weekly Property E-Newsletter
  • Sign up to be notified when we publish a new digital edition
Our Events
  • Sustainable Supply Chain Conference
  • Industrial & Logistics Property Conference
  • Supply Chain Excellence Awards
  • CiTTi Awards
  • Robotics and Automation Exhibition
  • IntraLogisteX
  • Sustainable Supply Chain Exhibition
© 2023 Akabo Media Ltd Registered No 07766641 England | All rights reserved.
Registered Office: Akabo Media, GG.007, Metal Box Factory, 30 Great Guildford St, SE1 0HS
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits.
By clicking “ACCEPT ALL”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
Cookie settingsRejectACCEPT ALL
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
CookieDurationDescription
__cf_bm30 minutesCloudflare set the cookie to support Cloudflare Bot Management.
_zm_chtaid2 hoursZoom sets this cookie to facilitate video conferences via zoom from the website.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
CookieDurationDescription
_ga1 year 1 month 4 daysGoogle Analytics sets this cookie to calculate visitor, session and campaign data and track site usage for the site's analytics report. The cookie stores information anonymously and assigns a randomly generated number to recognise unique visitors.
_ga_*1 year 1 month 4 daysGoogle Analytics sets this cookie to store and count page views.
_gat_gtag_UA_*1 minuteGoogle Analytics sets this cookie to store a unique user ID.
_gid1 dayGoogle Analytics sets this cookie to store information on how visitors use a website while also creating an analytics report of the website's performance. Some of the collected data includes the number of visitors, their source, and the pages they visit anonymously.
CONSENT2 yearsYouTube sets this cookie via embedded YouTube videos and registers anonymous statistical data.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
CookieDurationDescription
OAID1 yearCookie set to record whether the user has opted out of the collection of information by the AdsWizz Service Cookies.
VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE5 months 27 daysYouTube sets this cookie to measure bandwidth, determining whether the user gets the new or old player interface.
YSCsessionYoutube sets this cookie to track the views of embedded videos on Youtube pages.
yt-remote-connected-devicesneverYouTube sets this cookie to store the user's video preferences using embedded YouTube videos.
yt-remote-device-idneverYouTube sets this cookie to store the user's video preferences using embedded YouTube videos.
yt.innertube::nextIdneverYouTube sets this cookie to register a unique ID to store data on what videos from YouTube the user has seen.
yt.innertube::requestsneverYouTube sets this cookie to register a unique ID to store data on what videos from YouTube the user has seen.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
CookieDurationDescription
TS018dd1basessionDescription is currently not available.
TS01f92dc5sessionDescription is currently not available.
SAVE & ACCEPT
Powered by CookieYes Logo