Logistics Manager
  • Logistics
    • A-E
      • 3rd Party Logistics
      • Air Cargo
      • Coronavirus
      • Express & e-delivery
      • Editor’s Blog
    • F-M
      • Health & Safety
      • International logistics
      • Latest issue
      • Logistics & Supply Chain
    • O-Z
      • Ocean Freight
      • Policy and legislation
      • Professional development
      • Rail freight
      • Road transport
      • Sustainability
      • Temperature-controlled
  • Intralogistics
    • Automation
    • Commercial Vehicles
    • Equipment
    • Infrastructure & Services
    • IT & Software
    • Materials handling
    • Packaging
    • Picking and sortation
    • Robotics and innovation
    • Storage
  • Supply Chain
    • A-L
      • Automotive
      • Construction
      • Energy
      • Fashion
      • Food & drink
      • Forecasting
      • Healthcare and Pharma
      • Hi-tech
    • M-Z
      • Manufacturing
      • Military
      • Omni-channel
      • Public Sector
      • Retail
      • SME
      • Sourcing and procurement
      • Supply Chain Analysis
      • Supply Chain Awards
      • Supply Chain Strategy
      • Supply Chain Technology
      • Supply Chain Visibility
      • Technology
  • Property
    • A-M
      • Big Sheds
      • Design & Build
      • East Midlands and East Anglia
      • M25 East
      • M25 West
      • Mid-box
    • M-Z
      • North East & Yorkshire
      • North West
      • Scotland
      • South-West & Wales
      • Speculative Development
      • Urban Warehouses
      • West Midlands
  • Corporate Insight
  • Digital Magazines
    • June 2023
    • May 2023
    • April 2023
    • March 2023
    • February 2023
    • January 2023
  • Events
    • Sustainable Supply Chain Conference
    • ESG Industrial & Logistics Conference
    • Supply Chain Excellence Awards
    • CiTTi Awards
    • IntraLogisteX
    • Robotics & Automation
  • Webinars
LinkedIn Twitter
  • Subscribe
  • Free weekly e-newsletter
  • Free daily e-newsletter
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
LinkedIn Twitter
Logistics Manager
SUBSCRIBE >
  • Logistics
      • 3rd Party Logistics
      • Air Cargo
      • Coronavirus
      • Express & e-delivery
      • Editor’s Blog
      • Health & Safety
      • International logistics
      • Latest issue
      • Logistics & Supply Chain
      • Ocean Freight
      • Policy and legislation
      • Professional development
      • Rail freight
      • Road transport
      • Sustainability
      • Temperature-controlled
  • Intralogistics
      • Automation
      • Commercial Vehicles
      • Equipment
      • Infrastructure & Services
      • IT & Software
      • Materials handling
      • Packaging
      • Picking and sortation
      • Robotics and innovation
      • Storage
  • Supply Chain
      • Automotive
      • Construction
      • Energy
      • Fashion
      • Food & drink
      • Forecasting
      • Healthcare and Pharma
      • Hi-tech
      • Manufacturing
      • Military
      • Omni-channel
      • Public Sector
      • Retail
      • SME
      • Sourcing and procurement
      • Supply Chain Analysis
      • Supply Chain Awards
      • Supply Chain Strategy
      • Supply Chain Technology
      • Supply Chain Visibility
      • Technology
  • Property
      • Big Sheds
      • Design & Build
      • East Midlands and East Anglia
      • M25 East
      • M25 West
      • Mid-box
      • North East & Yorkshire
      • North West
      • Scotland
      • South-West & Wales
      • Speculative Development
      • Urban Warehouses
      • West Midlands
  • Corporate Insight
  • Events
    • Events News
      • Conferences
      • Exhibitions
      • Top 50
    • Sustainable Supply Chain Conference
    • Industrial & Logistics Property Conference
    • Supply Chain Excellence Awards
    • CiTTi Awards
    • IntraLogisteX
    • Robotics & Automation
  • Digital Magazines
    1. October 2023
    2. September 2023
    3. August 2023
    4. July 2023
    5. June 2023
    6. May 2023
    Featured

    Logistics Manager Magazine October 2023

    2nd October 2023By Michelle Mooney
    Recent
    2nd October 2023

    Logistics Manager Magazine October 2023

    4th September 2023

    Logistics Manager Magazine September 2023

    1st August 2023

    Logistics Manager Magazine August 2023

  • Webinars
LinkedIn Twitter
Logistics Manager
Robotics and innovation

Measures of distinction

Maria HighlandBy Maria Highland30th November 20219 Mins Read
LinkedIn Twitter Email Facebook

AGVs were a key starting point in the road to autonomous working. But, asks Maria Highland, is there still a place for them in today’s AMR warehouse?

Automated Guided Vehicles used to be what we called any unmanned device moving around the warehouse. Originally these would have been mainly forklift trucks moving along embedded tracks in the floor, with simple programming including sensors for safety. However, as technology has developed to allow more independent movement, the term ‘Autonomous Mobile Robot’ has become more apt. AGVs are still here although their role in the warehouse has changed.

You may ask, aren’t AGVs and AMRs the same thing by different names? “No,” says Rose Power, Head of Operations at Scurri (pictured below). “Due to the rigidity of how AGVs work compared with the flexibility of AMRs, I don’t believe it’s just semantics.”

That rigidity is not necessarily a drawback. Without the autonomy of their rivals, AGVs work particularly well for repetitive processes or for businesses whose product profile is finite, such as raw materials. Typically, they supply manufacturing lines, accessing racking, and transport finished goods to staging or storage areas.

Bridging the gap
AGVs are often used to bridge a gap in a production line, to travel where there’s insufficient access for heavy-duty machinery such as embedded conveyors. Part of the appeal is that they are a standalone technology that can fit within an established operation on a modular basis, as an alternative to renovating the entire warehouse with full-scale automation.

Opinion of difference

Although the distinction between AGVs and AMRs has blurred a little in the past few years, there remains a few general differences in the way they operate and how they are used. “AGVs enable fast material transport from A to B,” says Simon Jones, Head of UK & Ireland at 6 River Systems. “The tasks they are asked to do are clearly defined and repetitive such as pallet movement.” By contrast, AMRs use cameras and sensors to see what is around them and hold in their memory a digital map of the area they operate in. “They constantly verify their location and use ‘intelligence’ to work out the best route to their next destination, or an alternative route if the first choice is blocked,” Jones explains. “AMRs are ideal for assisting employees with complex tasks such as ‘each’ picking in a warehouse.”

AMRs are orchestrated by sophisticated software that takes the raw orders to be picked from the WMS and provides all the intelligence to sequence the picking operation in the most efficient manner, taking into account delivery times, congestion, size of the products to be picked, number of staff available, as well as many other configurable factors. The AMRs then guide the staff through the process as directed by the software as well as carrying the picked products to where they are needed.

“They provide adaptability to material flow,” reports Edward Hutchison, Managing Director of BITO Storage Systems (pictured below). “This kind of ‘partial automation’ can be a company’s first step on the automation path that, for many, will represent a more viable manual labour alternative than going directly for a complex, fully automated warehouse system.”

Labour shortages are a part of the Christmas peak, and as the problem gets worse than ever, the value of alternatives is rising. Many operators will find a place in the warehouse where an AGV could reap rewards, especially if they don’t have the scale to take on larger-scale automation. As a basis, anywhere that uses a forklift should consider whether it needs to be driven by a human or not. 

Paul Freeman of Toyota Material Handling reckons several factors are driving the market for AGVs. “Firstly, there is a shortage of skilled forklift operators. Secondly, the operational cost of automation is usually lower than manually operated processes. And thirdly, in this era of e-commerce, there is a need for streamlined delivery, which forces logistics providers to plan and predict their logistics flows more consistently
to achieve next-day or even same-day delivery.”

AGVs are one of the cheapest steps into automation, but Power points out the costs beyond unit price. “Although AGVs typically cost less per robot than AMRs, you must also consider the costs you will incur to set up, deploy, reconfigure and operate them. AGVs usually require the installation of physical guides, under-floor wiring, or surface tape to allow the AGV to navigate and locate itself in its surroundings. And if you need to install sensors beneath the floor, that means lost hours to renovation, plus the cost of the actual work.”

This will put off some prospective investors who may prefer AMRs that figure out the layout of the workspace themselves. But if the business case is there, there are enough offerings on the market to sidestep many of these hurdles. BITO’s LEO Locative, for example, does not require a costly control system or laborious installation procedure. “Users need only lay out a visible track on the floor for the AGV to follow,” says Hutchison. “Additional special markings ensure the system always knows where it is and therefore guides it reliably to all targets. The visual tracks and markings are easy to change or even completely remove so that new tasks can be set up in no time.”

For operations where AGVs will work, the value they can deliver is not to be sniffed at. Power points out that AGVs can improve health, safety and workplace ergonomics while also helping with the recruiting and retention of workers. “The end result is lower cycle times, more picking and less walking, eliminating the wasteful and unproductive walking time and making the workflow easier and much faster,” she says. “AGVs can dramatically improve worker productivity by two to three times, which leads to lower labour costs, higher pick rates and exceptionally faster cycle times.”

Helping hands

Digmesa makes precision flow sensors for fluids, as found in almost every coffee machine in the world. To keep up recent high demand, the firm has automated its Swiss factory with AMRs from KNAPP.

The Open Shuttle AMRs transport empty containers to injection-moulding machines and take finished products to a flow rack system. The containers are equipped with RFID tags to ensure traceability of the goods.

“Our injection-moulding machines run continuously, with 24/7 operation of our assembly machines, so optimal material flow is important, as is having no standstills,” explains Stefan, CEO of Digmesa. “This was critical for investing in an autonomous system that – without a driver – puts things in the right place.”

The Open Shuttle AMRs undertake smart path planning and independent management of orders. Each Open Shuttle features integrated intelligence, which enables it to autonomously plan its route to the target, detect obstacles and avoid them intuitively. This free navigation is based on the calculations of onboard laser scanners and software.

Another factor for Digmesa was the AMR’s lifting facility. “In comparison with other systems, with the Open Shuttle we can pick up and deliver at various heights,” adds Schneider. The integrated lifter on a KNAPP Open Shuttle enables it to pick up and deliver small load carriers at heights of 550-1,500mm. The lifter moves up or down automatically, while the Open Shuttle is on the move, to suit the next collection or delivery stop.

Freeman agrees that safe working is a key for efficiency that AGVs can help to deliver. “Because they follow the route around the warehouse that they have been programmed to follow – unlike most operator-controlled forklifts where there is temptation to take a potentially dangerous ‘quick cut’, which it seems is omnipresent among some drivers – the likelihood of an automated truck damaging either the warehouse building, the storage system within it or the load being carried is virtually zero. This built-in safety functionality also means that the risk of the equipment causing injury to warehouse personnel working in the same area as an automated machine is minimal.”

Flexible friends
Freeman also points out that AGVs uses less energy and can be expected to have a longer working life than a manually operated forklift. AGVs can offer exceptional value, but it will be for specific tasks or for certain areas of any operation. On the other hand, AMRs present a more versatile option. 

Scurri’s Power sums up the benefits of the ’bots. “A great AMR requires no alterations to your current facility, and can autonomously navigate through manufacturing and warehouse spaces. It learns its environment, remembers its location and dynamically plans its own path from one destination to another. If its path is blocked, an AMR can re-route itself with no assistance. The sensors an AMR uses to navigate ensure that it can operate safely in a dynamic environment alongside humans and materials handling equipment.”

Flexibility is an important differentiator, says Power. “As an AMR is not a permanent structure in the facility, it can be moved and redeployed with minimal cost as you grow and change over time. In fact, it can work in one part of the facility in the morning and be deployed for a different task later on.”

This versatility will be crucial for many businesses, especially SMEs going up against the big players. “AMRs offer tremendous flexibility and, importantly, scalability in traditional labour-intensive tasks such as order picking and put-away,” says Craig Whitehouse, Managing Director of Invar Integration (pictured below). 

In fact, Whitehouse reckons AMRs represent a potential advantage for smaller operators. “SMEs have a great opportunity to steal a march on larger retailers that may have committed to inflexible, fixed automated systems. By adopting intelligent software and advanced mobile robot technology, SMEs can leverage the flexibility, speed and performance of goods-to-person automation as a low-CapEx project.”

AMRs certainly offer a greater potential for smarter and dynamic automation. Power is categorical in her preference. “They are superior in terms of flexibility, cost-effectiveness, ROI and productivity optimisation. All companies will at some point ask themselves, ‘can we afford not to use AMRs?’`”

It’s a good question but there will undoubtedly be many businesses for which the answer is ‘yes’ – at least in certain areas. Manufacturing and warehousing will always involve processes that AGVs can optimise just as well as AMRs, and with a smaller price tag. They may be less flashy, but what AGVs do, they do well. Their role may be distinct but there is still a decided and valuable place for AGVs in today’s warehouses.

Share. LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email
Maria Highland

Related Stories

Hai Robotics unveils new robot and picking solution

2nd October 2023

GXO deploys AI to reduce emissions in Iceland supply chain

27th September 2023

Consortium makes first paperless cross-border shipment

25th September 2023
Latest News Stories
3rd October 2023

Bis Henderson Space and Consultancy relaunched as ‘Visku’

2nd October 2023

Godwin Developments secures 54-acre Northamptonshire site

2nd October 2023

West Midlands industrial estate acquired in joint venture

Free weekly e-newsletters

Discover what’s causing a stir in the world of logistics and supply chains


Key Content
  • Digital Magazines
  • Logistics
  • Intralogistics
  • Supply Chain
  • Property
  • Corporate Insight
  • Events News
  • Opinion
Akabo Media
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe
  • Free Daily E-Newsletter
  • Free Weekly Top Stories E-Newsletters
  • Free Weekly Supply Chain E-Newsletter
  • Free Weekly Property E-Newsletter
  • Sign up to be notified when we publish a new digital edition
Our Events
  • Sustainable Supply Chain Conference
  • ESG Industrial & Logistics Conference
  • Supply Chain Excellence Awards
  • CiTTi Awards
  • Robotics and Automation Exhibition
  • IntraLogisteX
© 2023 Akabo Media Ltd Registered No 07766641 England | All rights reserved.
Registered Office: Akabo Media, GG.007, Metal Box Factory, 30 Great Guildford St, SE1 0HS
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits.
By clicking “ACCEPT ALL”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
Cookie settingsRejectACCEPT ALL
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
CookieDurationDescription
__cf_bm30 minutesCloudflare set the cookie to support Cloudflare Bot Management.
_zm_chtaid2 hoursZoom sets this cookie to facilitate video conferences via zoom from the website.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
CookieDurationDescription
_ga1 year 1 month 4 daysGoogle Analytics sets this cookie to calculate visitor, session and campaign data and track site usage for the site's analytics report. The cookie stores information anonymously and assigns a randomly generated number to recognise unique visitors.
_ga_*1 year 1 month 4 daysGoogle Analytics sets this cookie to store and count page views.
_gat_gtag_UA_*1 minuteGoogle Analytics sets this cookie to store a unique user ID.
_gid1 dayGoogle Analytics sets this cookie to store information on how visitors use a website while also creating an analytics report of the website's performance. Some of the collected data includes the number of visitors, their source, and the pages they visit anonymously.
CONSENT2 yearsYouTube sets this cookie via embedded YouTube videos and registers anonymous statistical data.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
CookieDurationDescription
OAID1 yearCookie set to record whether the user has opted out of the collection of information by the AdsWizz Service Cookies.
VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE5 months 27 daysYouTube sets this cookie to measure bandwidth, determining whether the user gets the new or old player interface.
YSCsessionYoutube sets this cookie to track the views of embedded videos on Youtube pages.
yt-remote-connected-devicesneverYouTube sets this cookie to store the user's video preferences using embedded YouTube videos.
yt-remote-device-idneverYouTube sets this cookie to store the user's video preferences using embedded YouTube videos.
yt.innertube::nextIdneverYouTube sets this cookie to register a unique ID to store data on what videos from YouTube the user has seen.
yt.innertube::requestsneverYouTube sets this cookie to register a unique ID to store data on what videos from YouTube the user has seen.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
CookieDurationDescription
TS018dd1basessionDescription is currently not available.
TS01f92dc5sessionDescription is currently not available.
SAVE & ACCEPT
Powered by CookieYes Logo